“As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.”
In any serious kitchen, the sheet pan is more than just a flat tray—it’s a foundational tool. And when it comes to heat distribution, responsiveness, and durability, carbon steel baking sheets are in a league of their own. Used in commercial kitchens for good reason, carbon steel offers the heft and performance that seasoned chefs rely on for consistent results—whether you’re caramelizing root vegetables, flash-roasting proteins, or perfecting a golden, even bake on pastries.
In this article, we’ve explored and picked the top baking sheets which are made of carbon steel—covering everything from budget-friendly options to commercial-grade workhorses. Whether you’re looking to upgrade your sheet pan game or invest in a new kitchen staple, you’ll find the right fit from here.
List of 12 Best Carbon Steel Baking Sheets for 2025
12. Barlket 9×11 Inch Carbon Steel Nonstick Baking Sheet Tray Set – Heavy Duty Gold Cookie Pans (2-Pack)
The Barlket 9×11 Inch Nonstick Baking Sheet Set delivers impressive performance in a compact, elegant package. Made from heavy-gauge 0.31-inch carbon steel, these gold-finished trays are both durable and stylish—perfect for small-batch baking or cooking for two. The standout feature is its gold nonstick coating, which ensures effortless food release and easy cleanup. With its even heat distribution and oven safety up to 446°F, you’ll achieve evenly baked cookies, roasted vegetables, and crisped meats with no warping.
Compared to similar-sized pans, the Barlket trays offer better aesthetics and a thicker gauge at a very competitive price point. They’re also PTFE-free, adding peace of mind for health-conscious cooks. Ideal for beginners and experienced bakers alike, these pans are practical yet gift-worthy thanks to their premium design. At under $17 for a 2-pack, they offer excellent value for money without compromising quality.
Pros:
✅ Heavy-duty carbon steel construction
✅ Stylish gold nonstick coating
✅ Even heat distribution, no warping
✅ Easy to clean and PTFE-free
✅ Great value for a 2-pack
Cons:
❌ Not suitable for high-volume baking
❌ Smaller size may not suit larger ovens or big batches
11. GoodCook 3-Piece Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set – Small, Medium & Large Cookie Pans for Everyday Use
The GoodCook Everyday 3-Piece Baking Sheet Set is a versatile and budget-friendly choice for bakers of all skill levels. Constructed from durable carbon steel, these pans resist warping while delivering consistent, even heat distribution across all three sizes—13” x 9”, 15” x 10”, and 17” x 11”. Whether you’re roasting veggies, baking cookies, or preparing sheet pan dinners, this set has you covered.
What makes it stand out is GoodCook’s exclusive scratch-resistant nonstick coating, ensuring easy release and quick cleanup, even after sticky or sugary bakes. Compared to other baking sets in this price range, the quality and performance punch well above their weight. While they’re dishwasher-safe, hand washing is recommended to preserve the finish long-term. At just under $14 for a full trio of pans, it’s hard to beat this set for value and everyday performance.
Pros:
✅ Three useful sizes for different baking needs
✅ Durable carbon steel construction
✅ Scratch-resistant nonstick coating
✅ Even heat distribution with no warping
✅ Excellent price for a full set
Cons:
❌ Coating may wear with frequent dishwasher use
❌ Lacks the aesthetic appeal of premium sets
10. HONGBAKE 2-Pack Nonstick Half Sheet Baking Pans – 57% Thicker Carbon Steel Cookie Sheets in Champagne Gold (17.5″ x 12″)
Buy on Amazon.com
The HONGBAKE 2-Pack Half Sheet Baking Pans deliver commercial-grade performance with an upscale finish. Crafted from 57% thicker carbon steel, these pans offer exceptional durability and heat distribution, making them ideal for everything from cookies to roasted vegetables. Their diamond-textured base enhances airflow and nonstick performance, ensuring even baking and easy food release every time.
What sets this set apart is the double-layer, PTFE-free nonstick coating—reinforced with silicone and free from harmful chemicals—offering a healthier, scratch-resistant baking experience. Compared to similarly priced sheet pans, HONGBAKE stands out for both its design and performance. The champagne gold finish adds elegance, making it both a functional kitchen staple and a table-worthy serving tray. With heat resistance up to 450°F and a generous 17.5” x 12” size, this set is an excellent value for serious home bakers.
Pros:
✅ 57% thicker carbon steel for superior durability
✅ Diamond-textured nonstick surface
✅ Chemical-free, double-layer coating
✅ Even heat distribution, warp-resistant
✅ Elegant champagne gold finish
Cons:
❌ Slightly pricier than basic sheet pans
❌ Larger size may not fit compact ovens
9. GoodCook BestBake Nonstick Carbon Steel Cookie Sheet – Large 11″ x 17″ Textured Baking Pan with Even Heating & Scratch-Resistant Surface
The GoodCook BestBake 11″ x 17″ Cookie Sheet offers a smart blend of functionality and affordability for home bakers who want reliable results. Made from durable carbon steel, it resists warping and delivers even heat distribution for consistent baking. The standout feature is its diamond-patterned textured surface, which promotes airflow and ensures your baked goods cook evenly—no burnt edges or raw centers.
The scratch-resistant nonstick coating makes for easy release and cleanup, while its PTFE-free composition supports healthier baking. Thoughtfully designed with bakery-style angled walls, this sheet helps produce straighter, more professional-looking edges on cakes, bars, and cookies. For under $12, it’s one of the best-value large baking sheets available—comparable in performance to higher-priced competitors. Whether you’re whipping up sheet pan dinners or weekend cookie batches, this pan delivers with style and substance.
Pros:
✅ Durable, warp-resistant carbon steel
✅ Textured surface for even heating
✅ Scratch-resistant, non-toxic nonstick coating
✅ Angled edges for cleaner, professional results
✅ Affordable price for a large sheet
Cons:
❌ Not as thick or premium-feeling as higher-end pans
❌ Single pan—not a set
8. Tiawudi 3-Piece Nonstick Baking Sheet Pan Set – Heavy-Duty Carbon Steel with Diamond Texture, Warp-Resistant, Gray (Large/Medium/Small)
The Tiawudi 3-Piece Baking Sheet Pan Set brings professional-grade performance to your kitchen with a smart, versatile trio of carbon steel trays. Each pan is crafted from 0.8mm heavy-duty steel—twice as thick as many standard baking sheets—ensuring excellent durability, even heat distribution, and a warp-resistant structure, oven-safe up to 450°F.
The standout diamond-textured surface enhances airflow and boosts nonstick performance, helping cookies, veggies, and sheet pan meals bake evenly with minimal mess. The set includes three convenient sizes, ideal for everything from small batches to meal prep. It’s PTFE-, BPA-, and toxin-free, offering a safe and easy cleanup experience for everyday use. Compared to pricier competitors, Tiawudi’s set punches above its weight, delivering solid value and style at a budget-friendly price.
Pros:
✅ 3 versatile pan sizes (L/M/S)
✅ 2x thicker carbon steel for durability
✅ Diamond texture for even baking
✅ Chemical-free nonstick coating
✅ Great value for a multi-piece set
Cons:
❌ Hand washing recommended for longevity
❌ Heavier weight may be bulky for some users
7. GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set – 2-Pack Extra-Large 15” x 21” Cookie Sheets for Oven, Heavy-Duty Bakeware with Scratch-Resistant Coating
The GoodCook Everyday 2-Pack Extra-Large Baking Sheet Set is a powerhouse addition to any kitchen, especially for home chefs who bake in big batches. These 15” x 21” pans are crafted from durable carbon steel, offering excellent heat distribution and impressive resistance to warping—even with frequent, high-heat use.
Each sheet features a scratch-resistant, nonstick coating exclusive to GoodCook, ensuring effortless food release and minimal cleanup. Whether you’re prepping cookies for a crowd or roasting veggies for a sheet pan dinner, the generous size and sturdy design deliver consistent, evenly baked results. Compared to similar premium brands, this set offers exceptional value, balancing quality, performance, and size at a mid-range price point.
Pros:
✅ Extra-large size perfect for batch cooking
✅ Durable carbon steel resists warping
✅ High-quality nonstick surface
✅ Dishwasher safe (hand wash recommended for longevity)
✅ Great for cookies, meals, and more
Cons:
❌ Large size may not fit all ovens
❌ No textured base for enhanced airflow
6. GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set – 3-Pack Standard 13” x 9” Cookie Sheets for Oven, Durable Bakeware with Scratch-Resistant Coating
Buy on Amazon.com
The GoodCook Everyday 3-Pack Standard Baking Sheet Set (13” x 9”) is perfect for everyday bakers who value reliability and ease of use in a manageable size. Made with durable carbon steel, these sheets offer consistent heat distribution and hold up well to regular use without warping. The nonstick coating, exclusive to GoodCook, ensures your cookies and sheet-pan meals release effortlessly and cleanup is a breeze.
Compared to the GoodCook Extra-Large 15” x 21” Baking Sheets, this set offers greater flexibility and convenience for smaller ovens or limited counter space. While it doesn’t have the batch-baking capacity of the larger version, it’s ideal for everyday tasks like roasting veggies or baking smaller batches.
Pros:
✅ Standard size fits most ovens
✅ Great for small households or quick meals
✅ Durable carbon steel build
✅ Exclusive nonstick coating
✅ Budget-friendly 3-pack
Cons:
❌ Too small for large-batch baking
❌ No textured surface for airflow optimization
5. GoodCook 15” x 10.5” Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Sheet & Wire Rack – Versatile Oven Pan with Cooling Rack, Great for Crispy Bacon, Chicken, Fries & More
The GoodCook Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Pan with Wire Rack (15” x 10.5”) elevates everyday baking by combining a durable sheet pan with a versatile raised rack. Made with heavy-duty carbon steel, it ensures even heat distribution and resists warping over time. The included wire rack is perfect for crisping bacon, roasting chicken, or letting cookies cool, making this a multifunctional addition to your kitchen.
Compared to the GoodCook 3-Pack 13” x 9” Standard Baking Sheets, this combo stands out for its versatility—you can roast and crisp without flipping, and the rack helps drain grease for healthier results. It’s also slightly larger, offering more surface area, though it trades the convenience of a multipack for added function.
Pros:
✅ Includes raised rack for crisping/cooling
✅ Nonstick coating for easy release
✅ Durable carbon steel construction
✅ Great for bacon, wings, or baking
✅ Dishwasher safe
Cons:
❌ Single pan vs. 3-pack
❌ Slightly bulkier for small kitchens
4. Martha Stewart Gallen 15” x 10” Nonstick Carbon Steel Cookie Sheet – Cool Gray Bakeware for Cookies, Roasting, and Sheet Pan Dinners
Buy on Amazon.com
The Martha Stewart Gallen 15” x 10” Cookie Sheet blends sleek design with practical performance. Crafted from carbon steel, this pan offers quick heat response for even baking and roasting. The nonstick coating reduces the need for added oils, making it ideal for cookies, roasted veggies, or sheet pan meals. Its raised edges and rolled rims help prevent warping, while the cool gray finish adds style to functionality.
Compared to the GoodCook 15” x 10.5” Baking Sheet with Wire Rack, this Martha Stewart version is simpler—no rack included—but shines for minimalist bakers who prioritize a sleek, lightweight option. It’s not dishwasher safe, unlike some GoodCook pans, but its easy-clean surface compensates.
Pros:
✅ Lightweight with fast heat-up
✅ Sleek and modern finish
✅ Nonstick for easy release
✅ Great for quick bakes or roasting
Cons:
❌ No wire rack included
❌ Hand wash only
❌ Less heavy-duty than some alternatives
3. TeamFar 16” x 12” Carbon Steel Baking Sheet Set – 2-Pack Nonstick Oven Trays, Healthy Coating, Warp-Resistant for Cookies, Roasting & Reheating
The TeamFar 16” x 12” Baking Sheets bring together durability, size, and health-conscious design. This set of two is crafted from heavy-duty carbon steel with a PTFE-free nonstick coating that resists peeling and warping. The coating ensures quick release and easy hand-wash cleanup, though it’s not dishwasher safe. With a 1-inch deep rim, these pans are perfect for catching juices from roasting or baking without messy spills.
Compared to the Martha Stewart 15” pan, TeamFar offers a larger size and better edge design for preventing overflow, plus a two-pack for better batch baking. However, it lacks the brand cachet and sleek finish Martha’s line is known for. Still, for serious bakers or busy families, this set delivers high value.
Pros:
✅ Large 16″ size ideal for big batches
✅ Nonstick, PTFE-free coating
✅ Deep rim contains liquids
✅ Comes as a 2-pack
Cons:
❌ Hand wash only
❌ Coating may scratch with metal utensils
❌ No color or size variety in the set
2. NutriChef Nonstick Carbon Steel Cookie Sheet Set – 2-Pack Gold Bakeware with Raised Edges, PTFE/PFOA Free, 15” x 11” & 13” x 9”, Dishwasher Safe
The NutriChef Nonstick Cookie Sheet Set impresses with its durable construction, sleek gold finish, and practical raised-edge design. This 2-piece set includes a 15.7″ x 11″ and 13.4″ x 9.6″ baking sheet, offering flexibility for small or large batches. Made of engineered carbon steel with a PTFE, PFOA, and PFOS-free nonstick coating, these trays ensure easy food release and cleanup, and they’re dishwasher safe—a plus for busy cooks.
Compared to the TeamFar 2-pack, NutriChef offers a more elegant look, color options, and is dishwasher safe, whereas TeamFar’s black-coated pans are larger and feel sturdier for high-volume baking. NutriChef also sports a higher rim height (1.3″) which is great for juicy dishes or oven-roasted veggies.
Pros:
✅ Sleek gold finish with multiple color options
✅ 2 useful sizes for versatility
✅ Raised rim prevents spills
✅ PTFE/PFOA free & dishwasher safe
Cons:
❌ Not the thickest gauge steel
❌ Nonstick may wear over time with dishwasher use
❌ May not suit those needing oversized pans
1. GoodCook Everyday Nonstick Carbon Steel 9″ x 13″ Cookie Sheet – Heavy-Duty Oven Pan for Baking, Scratch-Resistant & Dishwasher Safe
The GoodCook Everyday 9” x 13” Nonstick Baking Sheet is a great pick for everyday kitchen tasks. It offers a balanced size for roasting vegetables, baking cookies, or preparing sheet pan dinners. Constructed with heavy-duty carbon steel, it resists warping and provides even heat distribution. Its nonstick coating is reliable, helping baked goods release cleanly and simplifying cleanup. It’s also dishwasher safe, though hand washing is ideal for longevity.
Compared to the NutriChef 2-piece set, the GoodCook version is simpler and more compact, great if you’re short on space or prefer a single, go-to tray. While NutriChef offers premium color finishes and two pan sizes, GoodCook delivers dependable performance at a lower price point, making it a smart choice for budget-conscious bakers.
Pros:
✅ Affordable and functional
✅ Even baking with warp-resistant steel
✅ Easy-to-clean nonstick surface
✅ Dishwasher safe
Cons:
❌ Only includes one pan
❌ No color variety
❌ Less suited for large-batch cooking
🔩 Material Composition: Is carbon steel baking sheet different from stainless steel?
Carbon steel and stainless steel baking sheets are definitely different — each with its own pros and cons, especially when it comes to baking and roasting. Here’s a quick comparison:
- Carbon Steel: Mostly iron with a small amount of carbon (no chromium).
- Stainless Steel: Iron alloyed with chromium and sometimes nickel to resist rust and corrosion.
🍪 Performance in the Kitchen
| Feature | Carbon Steel | Stainless Steel |
|---|---|---|
| Heat Conductivity | Excellent — heats up fast and evenly. | Decent, but not as efficient as carbon steel. |
| Responsiveness | Very responsive to temperature changes. | Slower to react to temp changes. |
| Nonstick Potential | Becomes more nonstick over time (with seasoning). | Sticks more unless lined with parchment or oiled well. |
| Durability | Very strong and warp-resistant. | Also durable but may warp under high heat. |
💦 Maintenance
- Carbon Steel: Needs seasoning (like cast iron). Can rust if not properly dried and oiled.
- Stainless Steel: Low maintenance. Dishwasher-safe and rust-resistant.
🧁 Best For…
- Carbon Steel: Roasting vegetables, baking cookies, high-heat searing. Great for browning!
- Stainless Steel: Everyday baking, sheet pan dinners, and for people who prefer low-maintenance tools.
Conclusion
If you’re going for performance and don’t mind a little upkeep, a carbon steel baking sheet is a fantastic choice. It offers superior heat conductivity, excellent browning, and durability that only gets better with seasoning over time. It’s perfect for serious home bakers and cooks who want professional-grade results and don’t mind the occasional maintenance to keep it in top shape. But if convenience and easy care are your top priorities, stainless steel might suit you better.
